Our journey through Advent continues with a rewind. We began last week in Mark 13, focused on the end of the world as Mark’s readers knew it. This week, we go back to the beginning of Mark’s Gospel, which means we are talking about John the Baptizer. Before we dig into the text, let’s set up the context.
Mark was written sometime around the year 70 CE. That is the most likely date, give or take a year or two, according to mainstream biblical scholarship. There are several reasons for this dating, among them 1) the apocalyptic text in Mark 13, which knows in some detail what the siege and destruction of Jerusalem were like, and 2) the route Jesus follows from Galilee to Jerusalem is considerably similar to the route the Roman military took to quell the Jewish revolt—from the north, in Galilee, to Jerusalem in the south.
This dating is interesting because it means that, for at least forty years after the life of Jesus, we do not yet have a birth narrative. That was first introduced in the 80s by Matthew. Mark begins with an adult Jesus who is drawn to the message of a wild wilderness prophet named John. With that context in mind, let’s explore how Mark begins his story of Jesus.
Mark 1:1-3, NRSVue
1. The beginning of the good news of Jesus Christ.
2 As it is written in the prophet Isaiah,
“See, I am sending my messenger ahead of you,
who will prepare your way,
3 the voice of one crying out in the wilderness:
‘Prepare the way of the Lord;
make his paths straight,’ ”
4 so John the baptizer appeared in the wilderness, proclaiming a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins.
1:1- The title of this gospel in not “The Gospel According to Mark.” That association with the “John Mark” of the Pauline and Pseudo-Pauline letters, and Acts, does not happen until later. According to a Eusebius, a fourth century church historian, it was in the first half of the second century that this connection was made by a bishop named Papias of Hierapolis. The problem with this is that we do not have Papias’s original writings, just a quote from Eusebius. Regard less of when the attribution to Mark became attached to this Gospel, it eventually did.
It seems Mark 1:1 is the intended title of the Gospel: The beginning of the good news of Jesus Christ. A note: Moving forward I will refer to the author as “Mark” for simplicity’s sake, because, though we do not know who actually wrote this Gospel, we have used “Mark” as the traditional identifier for the author of this text.
1:2-3 - Mark immediately grounds the story of Jesus in the story of the Hebrew Scriptures. Jesus does not represent a break with the tradition into which he was born. Jesus is thoroughly Jewish, and this is a Jewish story. Sadly, it did not take very long at all for the framing of the Jesus story to become grounded in antisemitism (the seeds of this are present even within the New Testament itself). Mark intends that we see this as a continuation of Israel’s story, not an abandonment of it.
With that in mind, we also should note that Mark flubs the attribution of his quotation here. Mark gives credit for the passage he references to the prophet Isaiah. In scholarship this would refer to “Deutero-Isaiah,” or “Second Isaiah.” If that’s an unfamiliar reference, let me briefly explain. Scholars see two to possibly three authors behind the prophetic text we call Isaiah. The “First” or “Proto-Isaiah” is found in chapters 1-39, and it reflects the work of the prophet Isaiah, son of Amoz, who was active in Judah in the 8th century BCE. This means the first 39 chapters of Isaiah reflect a pre-exilic context, meaning Judah had not yet been defeated and exiled by the Babylonians. “Second” or “Deutero-Isaiah,” consists of chapters 40-55, and is likely the work of a later generation. The context seems to be the sixth century BCE, during the Babylonian Exile. Finally, “Third” or “Trito-Isaiah, contains the final chapters of the book, 56-66, and reflects an slightly later period of the sixth century, after the exilic community had returned home to rebuild Judah.
Second Isaiah is responsible for verse three, and we find it in Isaiah 40:3:
“A voice cries out:
'In the wilderness prepare the way of the LORD;
make straight in the desert a highway for our God.’”
This is a reference to the return of the exiles from Babylon. Mark seems to understand, and wants to frame, his story of Jesus as a kind of return from exile. By the time Mark wrote, the Judean exiles had been home for hundreds of years. Yet, he chose this text to introduce and perhaps even describe the narrative he’s creating. The story of Jesus is a kind of return from exile.
The misattribution occurs in verse two. That reference is not from Isaiah, but the prophet Malachi. In chapter three, the prophet declares in the voice of the Divine, “See, I am sending my messenger to prepare the way before me, and the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple.” Mark mashes up these two texts and sees John the Baptizer are the messenger who was heralding the return of God to Israel. Though they were in the land of promise, they were not living with self determination. The Exile was geographically over, after all they were in the land, but they had not returned to the glory days of old. Rome ruled the world—their world—and they longed for God to return to them and make their world right.
1:4 - John the Baptizer emerged in the wilderness, raising the alarm that the time was coming soon, God would be returning to land, to the Temple, and that spelled the end of their exile. Note the location of John’s ministry. It evokes memories of the 40 years of wandering in the wilderness. The people wandered all those years because they did not trust God’s provision, and failed to keep God’s commands. John’s message of repentance and forgiveness, symbolized in the act of baptism, was about preparing the people for the return of God’s presence.
Also, by baptizing in the Jordan river, the story of John reminds us of Joshua and the Israelites entering the land, and the return from exile in Babylon. All the defining moments of Israel—Exodus and Exile—are taken in and symbolized in John’s wilderness activity.
Mark 1:5-8, NRSVue
5 And the whole Judean region and all the people of Jerusalem were going out to him and were baptized by him in the River Jordan, confessing their sins. 6 Now John was clothed with camel’s hair, with a leather belt around his waist, and he ate locusts and wild honey. 7 He proclaimed, “The one who is more powerful than I is coming after me; I am not worthy to stoop down and untie the strap of his sandals. 8 I have baptized you with water, but he will baptize you with the Holy Spirit.”
John’s movement must’ve been popular, and concerning for the power brokers and authorities, both the Roman and Temple establishments. Rome would often choose to keep a subjugated people in check by finding local collaborators. In first century Judea that would have been the Temple authorities. We remember Jesus’s protest against the Temple on Monday of Holy Week, but we can also see John’s movement similarly. He’s enacting ritual and calling the people to holiness outside of the established framework.
Then there’s John’s dress, intended to be reminiscent of the great prophet, Elijah. In 2 Kings 1:8, Elijah is described as, “A hairy man with a leather belt around his waist.” This is not simply cosplay; elsewhere in the Gospels John is understood to be the return of Elijah, as imagined by Malachi (4:5-6), “See, I will send you the prophet Elijah before the great and terrible day of the LORD comes. He will turn the hearts of parents to their children and the hearts of children to their parents, so that I will not come and strike the land with a curse.”
Finally, we find a theme that only grows and expands in the other Gospels, the subordination of John to Jesus. This likely reflects the fact that John’s popularity was significant and that, while Mark and the other Gospels seek to honor John and his importance, they want to do so without presenting him as having the same significance or similar impact as Jesus.
TAKEAWAYS
What are some takeaways from this text that we can offer to our communities? Let me suggest a few to get the ball rolling.
Repentance. Sadly, we most often hear this word through the bullhorns of street preachers. It is often assumed that to repent means “to feel bad” about something we have done, but that isn’t what the word means in either the Hebrew or Greek languages. To be sure, repentance can begin with feelings of sorrow or guilt, but the concept is far greater. To repent, in Hebrew, is shuv, and it means “to return, or turn around.” In Greek, it’s the word metanoia and it means “to change your mind.” Taken together, repentance isn’t about shame, it’s about seeing things differently, and changing direction as a result.
I hear often, usually on the internet, that I need to “REPENT!” My response is usually something like this: “I have…and do…and will continue to! That journey is how I have ended up where I am, and it will continue to shape who I become.” Perhaps we can encourage our listeners to think about their own journey with this concept, and ask if there is any change of direction or thinking with which they are wrestling.The importance of seeing the continuity. Jesus, both his message and his actions, only make sense within the framework of Second Temple Judaism. When we divorce Jesus from his context, he becomes transformed into something else and his message gets lost in the process. Instead of announcing good news for this world, we instead talk about what happens after we leave this world. Further, by beginning with the Hebrew Bible and connecting John to the figure of Elijah, Mark is connecting the Gospel and story of Jesus to the larger Jewish tradition. Jesus is not launching a new religion, but leading a reform and resistance movement within his tradition. Keeping that front and center allows us to hear the message of Jesus, and interpret the actions of Jesus, within the context in which he lived and worked.
A continuance from number two, we must challenge antisemitic readings of Scripture. Jesus was Jewish, and any reading of the Bible that pits Jesus against his own tradition has completely missed the point.
Engage the Elijah connection. Casting John as the returning Elijah is significant. Elijah did his work during the reign of King Ahab and Queen Jezebel, and his prophetic message was a direct condemnation of, and challenge to, Ahab’s leadership. Read Elijah’s story (1 Kings 17-2 Kings 2), and ask how this story impacts our understand of John. If Elijah was a prophet challenging a wicked king, how might John be doing something similar?
John raised the alarm. We might think of Paul Revere’s “midnight ride,” here. John is in the wilderness raising the alarm that the end of the age is fast approaching, and we need to be prepared and respond accordingly. Who are some other figures, past or present, who have similarly tried to get our attention to warn us of impending danger, to diagnose a sickness in our society, or call us to be prepared and transform the world?
I hope this helps get the ball rolling. I’d love to hear from YOU as you prepare to preach these texts. What direction did you take things? What did you learn or discover as you prepared? What surprised or challenged you? Let me know in the comments or in the chat! As always. if you find these posts helpful, please consider subscribing (if you haven’t) and also drop a like, comment, or share them.


Thank you for these posts. Will you also be doing a daily Advent reflection this year? If not I can go back to previous years. I enjoy your work and appreciate your work.
Thx